Trash hits! Why a wave of hedonistic, feral female pop stars are rejecting respectability

Pop and rock
Trash hits! Why a wave of hedonistic, feral female pop stars are rejecting respectability
Hannah Ewens
Fri 22 May 2026 09.00 CEST
News
https://www.theguardian.com/music/2026/may/22/trash-hits-hedonistic-feral-female-pop-stars-rejecting-respectability-slayyyter-cobrah

I f any year demanded a soundtrack of self-aggrandising female mayhem, it’s 2026. Amid the terrors of war, AI and the climate crisis, women are expected to be symbolic vessels of order and stability: thin, beautiful and perpetually 25 – a state of perfection newly available for purchase thanks to weight-loss drugs and the deep plane facelift .

Covered unironically in leopard print and rhinestones, a cohort of young female pop stars are defying this familiar con with brash electronic pop, shamelessly hedonistic lyrics, anarchic sexuality and an obsession with what was once dismissed as “white trash”. It’s an aesthetic embraced by performers such as Slayyyter , Kim Petras, Cobrah, Demi Lovato, Snow Strippers’ Tatiana Schwaninger, Tove Lo and returning scene godmother Kesha.

On I’m Your Girl Right, the lead single from her new album Estrus, Lo sings “We fuck all night on Ritalin-lin-lin-lin”. Slayyyter, meanwhile, describes herself as a “too drunk, trashy St Louis girl … extensions showing … looking kinda crazy”. Thong, a recent single by rising London-based musician Amara ctk100, celebrates barely-there pants (the artwork centres a thong visibly rising above the waistband of a skirt) and a fake-it-till-you-make-it lifestyle: “Benz outside / Oh no, I lied.”

“Part of this feels like an extension of post-lockdown nihilism,” says Ione Gamble, editor of the forthcoming essay collection The Polyester Book of (Bad) Taste . “Things are so bad in a political context that we may as well have fun.”

What sets this apart from previous moments of hard-partying recession pop is its reckless main character energy and invigorating rejection of feminine respectability. “The older I get, the more intense the pressure gets around being a ‘good woman’, and that mould feels so boring,” says Lo, who is 38. “There’s a confidence in not doing everything perfectly.”

Five years ago, sad-girl bedroom singer-songwriters such as Olivia Rodrigo and Holly Humberstone resonated with a generation spending their formative years in lockdown. Once the pandemic lifted, gen Z reclaimed feckless post-9/11 underground culture as “indie sleaze” and partied through the rubble of their own wrecked prospects. In came smudged eyeliner, shredded tights and the return of electroclash thanks to artists including the Dare and Fcukers .

That 00s sound is “definitely influencing music right now,” says Lo. She celebrates its “rawness and roughness”, which she thinks stemmed from “people not giving a fuck because they’re not being filmed” in an idyllic pre-cameraphone age. “That need to revolt against the norm is building inside us like a pressure cooker. The aggressive ‘getting punched in the face while I scream’ sonic landscape of Slayyyter’s song Crank makes that possible.”

In 2026, the influence of those scenes has mutated into sleazy electro-pop – from throbbing drum’n’bass to hyperactive EDM – delivered with rock-star energy and rap-influenced vocals. The production is aggressively maximalist, all grubby guitars, blown-out synths and addictive hooks. Meanwhile, its energy is rooted in impulsive, raunchy mid-00s US culture: MTV’s Spring Break, Britney with the brakes off, and the proliferation of online porn and reality TV (often both at once, in shows such as Girls of the Playboy Mansion).

Spilling out from Hollywood’s gay club scene, old pop songs by reality TV stars once dismissed as tacky – by the likes of Paris Hilton, Heidi Montag, The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills’ Erika Jayne – have been reclaimed as trash-pop ur-texts. Whether it’s Slayyyter screaming “I’m actually kinda famous” or Kim Petras flashing a Louis Vuitton bag and hard cash in her Freak It video, these stars are evoking a time when the rules of celebrity were changing and, for some, fame offered a diamante-encrusted ladder out of poverty.

You can hear early traces of the trash sound in the grimy raunch of early 00s electroclash icon Peaches and the knowing rap-influenced provocations of Princess Superstar, whose 2005 single Perfect had a gen Z-fuelled revival after it was used in Saltburn. Trash-pop was distilled in the mid-2000s Hollywood party scene, when figures such as EDM godfather Skrillex would party next to Hilton, a mix that inspired Porcelain Black. Then a teenage transplant to LA from Detroit, she was making a raucous mix of electro-pop and industrial club music with lyrics about being king of the world and “fucking like a star”. It got her signed to Virgin, who, she says, then panicked about her abrasive attitude and tried to push her into being “something like Avril Lavigne”. Black refused to comply and defied the label by uploading her songs to Myspace, earning millions of plays. “People dream of doing numbers like that online now,” she says.

But it wasn’t long before the music industry realised how lucrative this archetype was: in 2009, Kesha’s rambunctious debut single Tik Tok chimed with post-financial crisis nihilism and she was crowned the queen of pop excess. Last year, Slayyyter and Kesha collaborated with British producer Rose Gray on the club banger Attention! “My music would not exist without Kesha,” Slayyter has said.

Two years ago, Charli xcx’s Brat re-energised pop with hedonistic club energy, opening the cultural garbage chute for trash-pop to flow through. “Charli is an instigator and not a reactor,” says Lo. “Her sound is so infectious it’s impossible for it not to seep into everything new.” “It touched a nerve in the zeitgeist,” adds Slayyyter producer Kyle Shearer. “It hits, it feels good.”

Since Brat was her sixth album, Charli also offered a career blueprint for Slayyyter, whose third album, Wor$t Girl in America, swapped Hollywood glam for denim hotpants and trucker hats, and finally gave her the pop breakthrough she had been pursuing since 2018. By the time Slayyyter played to a huge crowd at Coachella this year, she had become one of US pop’s most talked-about artists. Charlie Harding, co-host of the podcast Switched on Pop, says the album represented “Slayyyter going for broke, her last-ditch effort. Pop music often rewards the thing which feels most authentically that person.”

Even if mainstream audiences have just caught on, the high camp, unapologetic brashness and full-frontal sexuality of trash pop has always attracted a huge LGBTQ+ audience – and artists from the community including Slayyyter, Petras, Swedish star Cobrah and US hyperpop rapper and producer (and early Slayyyter collaborator) Ayesha Erotica have been making this kind of music for years.

Off the back of this moment, Cobrah is now getting broader recognition for her aggressive, sexually charged club music, and was asked by Demi Lovato to feature on her new song Fantasy. Many of Cobrah’s songs – the industrial, icy Brand New Bitch, the hedonistic Good Puss – are about chasing extreme highs. “Everything else just feels very lame and tame,” she says. By leaning harder into her sexuality in her lyricism, she says, “I’ve become more like myself. The opposite of diluted: concentrated.”

Harding suggests that by revelling in hedonism, these artists are “straddling stereotypes of women being unhinged and hysterical while being the masterminds behind the whole endeavour”. You could read it as a reclamation of the mid-00s era, when dishevelled white-girl stars were assumed to be out of control: we know now that Hilton was just cosplaying as an airhead, although Britney Spears wasn’t so lucky, losing the right to run her own life when she was placed under a conservatorship that lasted 14 years .

“It’s an ‘early internet’ type of glamour that until very recently was still considered very low taste,” says Gamble. Slayyyter has named a song Brittany Murphy after the late Clueless and Girl, Interrupted star who died of pneumonia, anaemia and excessive prescription medication use in 2009, age 32. “Once-maligned women of that era are now being reappraised,” Gamble suggests.

This week, Slayyyter went on America’s Tonight Show for the first time wearing a bra made of beer cans , evoking an infamous scene in the Murphy-starring trailer-trash pageant movie Drop Dead Gorgeous . The knowing “white trash” aesthetic could be seen as reflecting and romanticising the economic reality for many in the US. In 2010, one reporter wrote of Kesha: “She’s this white-trash celebration. She’s where the lowbrow get to feel like the highbrow.”

Prof Robin James theorises that “if ‘white trash’ names whiteness that is threateningly close to Blackness, then white queer women performing ‘trashy’ femininity is a way for them to do something like a white girl equivalent of ‘ratchet’ – ie a femme sexuality that exists outside the boundaries of racialised, classed respectability.” She notes its debt to rap: “Of course, Black artists like Megan Thee Stallion and Cardi B did this half a decade ago.”

Major labels are taking note of how profitable this archetype is. Having started releasing her songs on SoundCloud, Slayyyter signed with Columbia for her latest album. Korean singer Heyoon, a former member of the squeaky-clean pop band Now United, recently released the hyperactive EP Seriously Unserious, reflecting the trash-pop sound’s incursion into the highly lucrative South Korean market. “I grew up a ‘performer’ which forced me to look perfect and do things perfectly,” she says. Pivoting to what’s “raw and messy” allowed her to leave behind the stress of striving for flawlessness. “It was a healing experience for me,” she says.

The sound is now so popular it’s already being satirised. Comedian Meg Stalter – of Hacks and Lena Dunham’s Netflix series Too Much – just launched a music career with the knowing Prettiest Girl in America, textbook trash-pop about how hard it is to be rich, famous and beautiful, which features a “tramp stamp” tattoo on its artwork.

While this aesthetic stands in stark contrast to a parallel wave of sleekly retro-styled pop stars such as Olivia Dean, Raye and Sienna Spiro, it arguably risks becoming just as contrived; the trash-pop look might suggest maxed-out credit cards, but underneath are financially savvy pop stars. However, culture critic Philippa Snow argues that gen Z is unlikely to care whether or not these artists are truly putting their crumpled dollars where their mouth is. “All trends are performative by nature, no?” she says. As for gen Z fans who adopt the look without the tequila habit to match, “maybe they’re on to something in the long run: we all brutalised our bodies in the 00s.”

Yet there’s more driving the trend than just the urge to have a good time. “People’s rights are being taken away from them,” says Harding. “Queer people, women, all deserve to be angry. This music turns frustration into celebration and hopefully on the other side, some kind of action.” And Lo says: “Just letting that inner turmoil out and letting it roam is cathartic as fuck. I’m happy many of us are realising that.”

Tove Lo’s album Estrus is released via Pretty Swede/Virgin on 18 September. Cobrah’s album Torn is out now via Atlantic. Amara ctk100’s self-released single Thong is out now

‘Knicks in four!’ rings out at MSG as New York take 2-0 lead over Cavs in East finals

NBA
‘Knicks in four!’ chants ring out at MSG as New York take 2-0 lead in East finals

Fri 22 May 2026 14.17 CESTLast modified on Fri 22 May 2026 14.46 CEST
News
https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2026/may/22/knicks-cavaliers-nba-playoffs-eastern-conference-finals

Josh Hart scored a playoff career-high 26 points, Jalen Brunson had 19 points and 14 assists, and the New York Knicks moved halfway to their first NBA finals appearance since 1999 by beating the Cleveland Cavaliers 109-93 on Thursday night at Madison Square Garden.

Mikal Bridges also scored 19 points and Karl-Anthony Towns had 18 points and 13 rebounds for the Knicks, who won their ninth straight game. It is the NBA’s longest postseason winning streak since the Boston Celtics won 10 straight on their way to the 2024 championship.

Hart went 5 from 11 from three-point range and also had seven assists.

“Just a whale of a game from Josh,” Knicks coach Mike Brown said.

Two nights after rallying from a 22-point deficit in the fourth quarter, the Knicks made sure they would be in control late with an 18-0 run in the third quarter that gave them a 71-53 lead. Fans chanted “Knicks in four! Knicks in four!” in the final minute, long after the starters had gone to the benches.

“In our mind it’s 0-0. We’ve got to win the next game. It’s the most important game of the year and that’s how we treat it,” Towns said.

Donovan Mitchell scored 26 points and James Harden had 18 for the Cavaliers, who will have to climb out of a 2-0 deficit for the second straight round. They host Game 3 on Saturday.

“Nothing to hang our head about,” Mitchell said. “They protected home court, and we’ve seen this before so we’re going to go to Game 3.”

The Knicks are in the Eastern Conference finals for the second straight year but haven’t played for the championship since losing to the San Antonio Spurs in 1999.

Brunson scored 38 points in the Game 1 comeback. He had only two points in the first half Thursday before making the first basket of the run that broke open the game and finished the highest assist total of his playoff career.

Hart burned a Cavaliers defensive strategy that seemed built around leaving him open from long range after he was benched for the rally in Game 1, playing just three minutes combined in the fourth quarter and overtime.

The forward had been shooting just 26.7% from three-point range and after a third straight miss from long range early Thursday, he put his jersey in his mouth and bit it, bouncing the ball down hard in frustration three times. But he kept firing.

“I knew I had to just keep shooting and if I did that I’d be good,” Hart said.

Mitchell got off to a slow start with just seven points in the first half, triggering more of the questions that followed Game 1 about whether he was injured.

Cleveland cut it to single digits with just under eight minutes left but ruined any chance of getting closer with poor free-throw shooting, missing 10 in the game and finishing at 68.8%. The Knicks eventually pushed their lead to 19 points.

Qatar sends mediators to Tehran in sign talks to reopen strait of Hormuz are reaching climax

US-Israel war on Iran
Uranium and control of strait of Hormuz key as talks to end US-Iran war continue
Patrick Wintour
Fri 22 May 2026 13.24 CESTLast modified on Fri 22 May 2026 13.25 CEST
News
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/may/22/uranium-strait-of-hormuz-us-iran-war-talks-pakistan

Future control over the strait of Hormuz and a demand from Washington that Tehran export its stockpile of highly enriched uranium remain key stumbling blocks, as Pakistani mediators continued to seek a permanent ceasefire they believe is still within reach between the US and Iran.

Meanwhile, Israel and Iran each fear the other is about to launch a surprise attack on its territory while the US president, Donald Trump, continues to insist a fresh assault on Iran is an option available to him.

The Pakistani interior minister, Mohsen Naqvi, met the Iranian foreign minister, Abbas Araghchi, for the second time in two days in a bid to secure a breakthrough in talks, and it is still possible that a delayed visit to Tehran by Field Marshal Asim Munir, the commander of the Pakistani army, will signal progress is being made.

Munir had been due in Tehran on Thursday, but a lack of progress in the talks postponed his arrival and it may be that Pakistan will try to bring in China as a mediator. Pakistan’s prime minister, Shehbaz Sharif, is due in Beijing on Saturday.

Iran has emphasised it is seeking to postpone all talks on its nuclear program and focus instead on a permanent cessation of hostilities that it hopes will include a phased lifting of US sanctions, unfreezing of frozen Iranian assets, compensation for US-Israeli war damage, and commitments not to resort to force in future. The future management of the strategic strait of Hormuz is a key point of dispute, with Pakistan floating plans for joint control under UN auspices

Tehran has also proposed that its recently created Persian Gulf Strait Authority take responsibility for the channel, in which fees would be charged and ships would have to follow instructions from over selected transit routes. The Iranian ambassador to France confirmed that Iran was seeking Oman’s cooperation with the plan.

Five Gulf states have written a letter to the International Maritime Authority, a global shipping watchdog, urging merchant and commercial ships not to engage with the PGSA.

The list of signatories are Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates. It does not include Oman, but Oman, which under the proposal would be the authority on the south side of the strait, is wary of Teheran’s proposal.

In their letter, the five states warn: “Iran’s purported route should be seen for what it is, an attempt to control traffic through the strait by forcing vessels to use a route within its territorial waters, which can be exploited for monetary gain through the imposition of toll fees. Any understanding or recognition of Iran’s proposed route and PGSA as an alternative would set a dangerous precedent.”

At a Nato foreign ministers meeting in Sweden the US secretary of state, Marco Rubio warned: “Iran is trying to create a tolling system. They’re trying to convince Oman… to join them in a tolling system in an international waterway. There is not a country in the world that should accept that.”

He again expressed his disappointment at Europe’s refusal to do more to keep the strait open.

Meanwhile, analysts argue that much of what US administration officials say about the status of the talks has to be filtered through Washington’s need to massage the global price of oil down.

Esmail Baghaei, spokesperson for the Iranian ministry of foreign affairs, told state media: “At this stage, the focus of the negotiations is on ending the war on all fronts, including Lebanon, and the claims made in the media about nuclear issues, including the issue of enriched material or the enrichment debate, are merely media speculation and lack credibility.”

Baghaei was referring to speculation that has arisen after Trump’s statements on Thursday when he spoke about Iran’s stockpile of highly enriched uranium. He said: “We will get it. We don’t need it, we don’t want it. We will probably even destroy it after we get it, but we will not let them get it.”

Russia has offered to receive the stockpile, but Iran says it will downblend the stockpile inside Iran itself.

Andy Robertson: ‘It was easy to fall in love with Liverpool – I’m fortunate Liverpool fell in love with me’

Liverpool
Andy Robertson: ‘It was easy to fall in love with Liverpool – I’m fortunate Liverpool fell in love with me’
Andy Hunter
Thu 21 May 2026 23.30 CEST
News
https://www.theguardian.com/football/2026/may/21/andy-robertson-liverpool-farewell-highs-lows-anfield

T here was the Barcelona comeback on the night he ruffled Lionel Messi’s hair, the Champions League triumph in Madrid , winning Liverpool’s first league title in 30 years and pressing five Manchester City players in one career-defining run at Anfield when 4-1 up. But the best feeling Andy Robertson experienced at Liverpool was “climbing the mountain” with Jürgen Klopp’s all-conquering team. Nobody climbed higher or harder.

The boy who was rejected by Celtic at 15 and tweeted: “Life at this age is rubbish with no money” after his debut for Queen’s Park aged 18 became the man many consider to be Liverpool’s finest left-back, and arguably the best in the world at his peak. With 377 fiercely committed appearances in a Liverpool shirt behind him, Robertson will say goodbye on Sunday. The 32-year-old Scotland captain leaves “with no regrets, no bitterness” and “glad that one of our Egyptian friends might take a bit more of the limelight. I can just sneak underneath that.”

As one of the most identifiable and popular players of the past nine years, there is no chance the £8m signing from Hull will be granted a quiet exit. Robertson is “gutted” it is coming to an end – “Everyone’s gutted when you leave Liverpool,” he says – but is filled mostly with pride at overcoming his initial insecurity to cement a place in Anfield folklore. It was quite the ride.

“We were on the most amazing journey ever, all together,” he reflects. “When we started out Mo Salah didn’t sign as the best player in the world or the best winger in the world. Virgil van Dijk had the potential to be but wasn’t the best centre-back in the world. Alisson wasn’t the best goalkeeper in the world. Trent [Alexander-Arnold] wasn’t the best right-back in the world. Hendo [Jordan Henderson] was still trying to find his feet as captain. We were all just on this journey from the bottom to the very top together and climbing that mountain was the best feeling ever.

“Every day we came in knowing we were getting better and better and starting to click as a team. We’d beat teams in the tunnel. Genuinely. When I speak to my Scotland teammates, they were lining up in the tunnel and looking over thinking: ‘We’re going to need to run our socks off today to get anything.’ And more often than not they didn’t get anything.

“We had an unbelievable environment to express ourselves, to play with freedom, but in our minds we knew we had to work at 100%. That was obviously from the manager, from the coaches, and I think then all the staff and people behind the scenes bought into it and you had the whole training ground determined to achieve all our dreams. Everyone was on the same page and we just made magical things happen thankfully.”

Robertson’s reminiscence prompts an inevitable follow-up. Why does Liverpool not feel like that now? His reply stops everyone in their tracks, and brings home the tragic reality of what this season has entailed for the now deposed Premier League champions. “In terms of the club I am leaving behind I think we are not at the 2017 stage, we are at the transition stage,” begins one of Diogo Jota’s closest friends. The Liverpool forward’s death in a car crash alongside his brother in north-western Spain last July cast a dark pall over the campaign

“This year hasn’t worked out for a variety of reasons. We can’t hide away from it, and it is not an excuse, but what we went through in the summer no team will ever go through. No member of staff will go through. I hope they never go through it because the devastation we went through … football didn’t matter. We didn’t care about football for weeks. None of us wanted to train. You were getting treatment off physios and physios didn’t want to treat you. That is the reality of it.

“As footballers we of course have a duty, we have to move on and we managed that. We started the season fairly well although it was still an emotional time for us. The [season-opening] Bournemouth game was ridiculously emotional with all of Jots’ family being there. I think after the 20th minute you saw a real dip in performance because of the emotional impact that it had on all of us.

“But then the season has been inconsistent. We bought players that we all got excited about, and they will all have an unbelievable career at Liverpool. I have no doubt about that. But they are also young. The one thing I get annoyed about in football is that footballers do not control their price tag. The market controls it. These players will be successful for Liverpool but they probably need a bit of time.

“Then some players who have played at a ridiculously high level haven’t played to that level. If you add all that in then we have had an inconsistent season and that is the huge frustration for us. We have been too easy to play against. There is no hiding away from that but I believe they have more than enough in that changing room to be successful for Liverpool again.”

Robertson received a farewell gift this week from Alexander-Arnold, who sent an image of the two of them celebrating the 2019 Champions League final victory over Tottenham. The message attached almost moved him to tears. The pair pushed each other to world-class levels and reworked the role of a full-back. There were the assists, naturally, while Robertson became the pressing machine that Klopp demanded. One press in particular, when he chased City players across the Anfield pitch in January 2018, will be forever part of the Scot’s Liverpool story.

“Everyone still talks about it because I think that was the moment people could see I could potentially be the left-back for years to come,” he says. “I’m not saying it would have been nine years, but that was a moment in a big game against the best team in the world at that time, I think fans left that stadium thinking: ‘We could have a proper left-back here.’

“I believe that was the game I finally belonged in a Liverpool jersey. That was the moment I really felt: ‘I belong at this football club, I am worthy of the shirt and I’m worthy of being here.’ Everything went straight up from there. That’s why when I look back now, I do so with a massive smile on my face because it’s the moment that made me sit here nine years later.”

Born in Glasgow, Made in Liverpool reads the inscription on a new mural of Robertson that has been painted near Anfield. His connection with the city is another source of pride. He says: “Liverpool and Glasgow are very similar cities and they are very similar people with similar things that are important to them.

“I think that’s why it has been so easy for me to fall in love with this city. I’m very fortunate that a lot of people in this city have then fallen in love with me. I think they saw a player out on that pitch who, if they could get a chance to put on a Liverpool shirt and play in a competitive game, they would play similar to me in terms of giving 100% and always being at it. I put a lot of pressure on myself to try and do that and I’m very grateful to the people for how they accepted me.”

Andy Burnham’s Manchester has a defining spirit – and Britain could do with a lot more of it | John Harris

Andy Burnham
Andy Burnham’s Manchester has a defining spirit – and Britain could do with a lot more of it
John Harris
Fri 22 May 2026 09.00 CESTLast modified on Fri 22 May 2026 09.38 CEST
News
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/may/22/andy-burnham-manchester-unique-spirit-britain-westminster

A mong the underrated later work of those revered sons of Manchester the Smiths, there is a completely jaw-dropping song simply titled London . Full of fury and excitement, it depicts a Mancunian as he boards a train, travelling to the capital full of ambition and hope, but also gripped by a gnawing ambivalence. Andy Burnham, whose love of the band is hardly a surprise, may well recognise not only its defining theme, but the song’s accidental encapsulation of his decision to try to make his way to the House of Commons, in a line crooned by Morrissey in slightly mocking tones: “And do you think you’ve made the right decision this time?”

Even if some observers only give him a 45% chance of winning , it looks like Burnham has, particularly when it comes to his pitch for power. Eleven years ago, let us not forget, a somewhat different incarnation of the future Greater Manchester mayor was one of four candidates for the Labour leadership, along with Jeremy Corbyn, and chose to stage one of his launch events at the City of London HQ of the auditing firm Ernst & Young. There he said he might back further benefit cuts , and claimed that too many people associated Labour with “giving people who don’t want to help themselves an easy ride”. In 2022, he told me this was the result of bad advice: “I listened to people that I shouldn’t have, really. It was tone-deaf … it wasn’t me. It wasn’t authentic.”

Some look at the 2026 model and see the same brazen shape-shifter. But having watched him closeup, I would argue that his progress over the last decade or so – he first became mayor of Greater Manchester in 2017 – has really been a contrasting story of rising certainty and self-confidence, deepening engagement with some of the more vibrant forces on the centre-left – such as Compass, the pressure group that gives a platform to both Labour and non-Labour voices – and the resulting ability to connect with crowds that most political figures would leave cold (witness two recent appearances at Glastonbury). But his most important attribute is a reflection of the dead end reached by Keir Starmer: the fact that Burnham has a lot of actual ideas. Remember those?

This week, he spoke at the Great North Investment Summit in Leeds, an event centred on devolution. He talked about people’s complete loss of faith in politics, and made one of his most well-trodden arguments: that for 40 years, this country has simply been on the wrong path. In keeping with an unabashedly partisan account of the UK’s past disasters and missteps, he lamented the “draining away of economic, social and political power” from the north of England, compounded by “deregulation, privatisation … and austerity”, and local economies whose wealth was siphoned “into the hands of people for whom life was already very good”. The signs of this shift include “people paying over the odds for the daily basics: energy, housing, water, transport”.

This is not particularly sophisticated stuff, but that is surely part of its power. Burnham’s conception of the north’s recent past is the crux of “ Manchesterism ” – the work-in-progress credo, with its backhanded reference to 19th-century free-trade Manchester liberalism , that he now draws on whenever he speaks. It begins with an account of history that emphasises deindustrialisation, and the convulsions of the 1980s (Margaret Thatcher is referenced in the first 35 seconds of his first Makerfield campaign video , soundtracked by Elbow’s One Day Like This). There is also a pointed emphasis on social housing, and the fact that rising so-called welfare bills are an indication of economic and social failure rather than worsening national delinquency.

The worst of modern capitalism, Burnham insists, is cynically extractive and socially damaging (shades here of Ed Miliband’s old argument about the difference between “predators” and “producers”). In its view of Westminster’s dysfunctional dominance, meanwhile, Manchesterism offers something so far monopolised by Nigel Farage: a specifically English critique of our broken systems of politics and power, the product of Burnham’s re-invention as a political outsider.

The core of all this is what Mathew Lawrence, the director of the thinktank Common Wealth, calls “ the productive state ”, in a new book about Manchesterism that he has co-authored of the same name. “Where the market coordinates and the welfare state redistributes, the productive state produces: directly owning and operating capital in essential sectors, participating in markets as builder and provider rather than as regulator or redistributor,” Lawrence says. “It is the return of sovereign economic control of the economy’s foundations.”

Reflected in Burnham’s pledge to bring energy and utilities under “stronger public control”, this foundational principle partly inspired one of modern Manchester’s ubiquitous features: the Bee Network. These yellow buses – with their uniform £2 fare – have finally brought order and coordination to a public transport system torn asunder by the Thatcher government’s deregulation of 1986. There is an interesting historical parallel here: just as the blessed Margaret avenged postwar social democracy at 40 years’ distance, so Burnham is set on “rolling back the 80s”.

And then there are the overarching vibes, and what the word “Manchester” evokes. No one should swallow any idea of the city as a progressive utopia: rough sleepers have long bedded down in the shadow of impossibly pricey apartments, and there is a painful income, wealth and influence gap between Greater Manchester’s north and south. But Burnham’s Manchesterism is clearly intended to build on the unquestionable successes that began with the miraculous regeneration delivered by the former city council leader Richard Leese and his chief executive Howard Bernstein . It conjures up images of a city centre where consumerist wonderment sits in the midst of a culture that is both entrepreneurial and collectivist. If Manchester has a prevailing spirit, this is probably it – and the UK could do with a lot more of it.

Perhaps in response to Burnham’s radicalism, things are now moving fast at the top of Labour, as evidenced by Rachel Reeves’s new commitment to a summer of cost-of-living activism and that supposed Blairite Wes Streeting’s conversion to the idea of a wealth tax. Meanwhile, Burnham’s naysayers make sneering reference to the gilt market, and question how much his agenda might actually cost.

Personally, I like Manchesterism for much the same reason as I like that aforementioned Smiths song: its ferocity, bile, energy and sense of purpose. Who knows what will happen in Makerfield, where the odds are so finely balanced? If Burnham became PM, how would he re-orientate Whitehall to even start to deliver what he wants in short order? So far we only know this: that his ideas have brought ideological oomph – not to mention hope – to a Labour party that was in dire danger of reducing politics to technocratic misery. And for that, we should be truly thankful.

John Harris is a Guardian columnist

Or, the Whale album review – Caroline Shaw and Andrew Yee collaboration offers intimacy and joy

Classical music
Or, the Whale album review – Caroline Shaw and Andrew Yee collaboration offers intimacy and joy
Clive Paget
Fri 22 May 2026 08.00 CESTLast modified on Fri 22 May 2026 08.02 CEST
News
https://www.theguardian.com/music/2026/may/22/or-the-whale-album-review-caroline-shaw-andrew-yee

I n one sense, this eight-track collaboration between Pulitzer prize-winning composer-vocalist Caroline Shaw and Grammy award-winning cellist-composer Andrew Yee is a snapshot of a friendship. The title – Or, the Whale – comes from Melville’s Moby-Dick, and in particular from director Wu Tsang’s 2022 silent film version for which Shaw and Yee provided the score. A condensed suite combines cello, electronics and ethereal vocals in a haunting, folk-infused evocation of the novel, whale song and all.

Much here is similarly imaginative. Yee’s uplifting The Trees of Green-Wood channels Meredith Monk as Shaw sings a catalogue of trees organised by diameter of trunk: the greater the girth, the louder the music. Sophisticated processing and intricate engineering, crucial elements throughout, add to the heady aural atmosphere. Another duet, Shenandoah, is a tender, exploratory arrangement of the traditional shanty.

Shaw’s versatile vocals and Yee’s emotive cello are at the centre of everything. An outlier movement from Messiaen’s Quartet for the End of Time finds Messiane’s piano replaced with a vocal harmoniser, while a repurposed early work by Shaw incorporates audio snippets of quilters living in North Carolina. Like everything here, the feeling of artistic intimacy and joy in the music-making is palpable.

Listen on Apple Music (above) or Spotify

The Pep years: season by season, how Guardiola’s Manchester City evolved

Pep Guardiola
The Pep years: season by season, how Guardiola’s Manchester City evolved
Will Unwin
Fri 22 May 2026 15.00 CESTLast modified on Fri 22 May 2026 15.02 CEST
News
https://www.theguardian.com/football/2026/may/22/the-pep-years-season-by-season-guardiola-manchester-city

2016-17: no silverware in first campaign

It was confirmed on 1 February that Pep Guardiola would be heading to east Manchester to try his hand at English football. Behind the scenes, plenty went on to create a squad suited to him but, in truth, it was a season of transition as the new head coach investigated who could fit into his system and what needed to change. It was soon apparent how influential the era-defining Kevin De Bruyne would be for Guardiola, as his class in midfield shone. City showed promise but finished third in the Premier League and were knocked out by Monaco in the Champions League last 16 as the new head coach began without a trophy.

2017-18: Premier League centurions

Bernardo Silva, Kyle Walker and Ederson headlined the summer business, while plenty of long-serving players were shipped out. Everything was in place for Guardiola’s revolution and City did not disappoint, dropping two points in the opening 20 Premier League matches. Liverpool were thrashed 5-0 in the fourth game of the campaign but got their own back by dumping City out of the Champions League in the quarter-finals. The first trophy of the Guardiola era was collected at Wembley, Arsenal the victims in the League Cup final . No one could compete and the title inevitably followed, City reaching the 100-point mark and scoring 106 goals as they showed they were the great entertainers, finishing 19 points clear of second-placed Manchester United.


2018-19: domestic treble winners

A comparatively poor 98 points and 95 goals followed but every single one was vital as Jürgen Klopp’s Liverpool fought City until the bitter end. The two clubs exchanged the lead at the top of the table 32 times over the course of the season. City won their final 14 league matches on their way to domestic glory, lifting the League Cup and the FA Cup along the way. It was an English team that would ruin the European dream once more, as Tottenham surprisingly eliminated City in the Champions League quarter-finals on away goals after a dramatic tie in Manchester.

2019-20: dethroned as Covid hits

City fell spectacularly short in the league, finishing 18 points adrift of Liverpool. Covid’s intervention made it an unusual season, as the two legs of the Champions League last 16 were played four months apart. A 4-2 aggregate win over Real Madrid felt like a turning point in Guardiola’s European journey with City but they went on to lose to Lyon in a one-off quarter-final in Lisbon. City did not finish empty-handed thanks to a 2-1 League Cup win over Aston Villa as Sergio Agüero and Rodri proved their class for Guardiola.

2020-21: champions again but Euro agony

Getting humiliated 5-2 at home against Leicester made Guardiola quickly realise all was not right. To cut a long story short, £60m was spent on bringing in the centre-back Rúben Dias and City went on to win the league 12 points ahead of Manchester United in a season largely played in front of empty stands. The League Cup found its way into the cabinet and the Champions League trophy was in sight for Guardiola and City for the first time in his tenure. They breezed to the final where they faced Chelsea, who finished fourth in the Premier League, in Porto, but Guardiola left out the defensive midfielder Rodri and City lost to Kai Havertz’s goal , a frustrating ending.

2021-22: Gündogan heroics on final day

Everything went down to the final day, with City needing to beat Aston Villa to guarantee a fourth title of the Guardiola era. The visitors went two goals ahead and, with 15 minutes remaining, Liverpool needed to score once to go top. Two of the greats of the Guardiola epoch stepped up, Ilkay Gündogan and Rodri levelling matters before a third goal, and a second from the German, in the space of five minutes turned everything around in chaotic style to create one of the most memorable ever finishes to a season . City’s Champions League exit was equally ludicrous, losing 6-5 on aggregate to Real Madrid after extra time. They were heading through at 90 minutes of the second leg, only to concede twice and eventually bow out .


2022-23: European champions at last

This was the year everything fell into place for Guardiola and City. He changed his style, signing Erling Haaland to play as a No 9, transforming the nature of the team. The Norwegian went on to score 52 goals across all competitions. The investment and tactical flexibility paid off as City bulldozed their way to the Champions League final. In the knockout stages RB Leipzig, Bayern Munich and Real Madrid were beaten 14-0 on aggregate at the Etihad Stadium. It was a nervous final against Inter in Istanbul but Rodri earned Guardiola the historic victory he craved and the treble in the process. “It was written in the stars. It belongs to us,” Guardiola said.


2023-24: English title No 6

How do you follow up a treble? By winning the final nine games to beat Arsenal to the title by two points for Guardiola’s sixth Premier League triumph. Real Madrid were once again a thorn in Guardiola’s side, beating City on penalties in the quarter-finals of the Champions League having drawn 4-4 on aggregate. Further upset was to come in the FA Cup final when they lost to their bitter foes Manchester United 2-1 at Wembley . Guardiola also said goodbye to Klopp, who left Liverpool after years of touchline battles. “They have been our biggest rivals,” Guardiola said. “And personally he has been the best rival I ever had in my life – in Dortmund when I was in Bayern, then here.”

2024-25: changing of the guard

The campaign was a disaster by Guardiola’s standards as City struggled to compete on any level. “If this were Barça or Madrid, they would have sacked me,” Guardiola said. There was loyalty to players who had brought the club so far but it was, arguably, a year too many for Walker and De Bruyne. There was surgery on the squad in January as City battled even to qualify for the Champions League in a season that would end without any major trophies in the cabinet. Their best shot at glory was in the FA Cup but City meekly lost to Crystal Palace 1-0 to add a further footnote to the misery.

2025-26: going out with a bang

A further rebuild in the summer brought together a fresh and vibrant squad but there was plenty of work to be done to get it into Guardiola’s mould. It was a slow-burner, City losing two of their opening three league games and, after four games without a win in January, challenging for first looked nigh-on impossible. City were resurgent, however, and made Arsenal sweat almost until the end.

The cups were more fruitful as Mikel Arteta’s side were brushed aside in the League Cup final and Chelsea beaten in the FA Cup final. Once again Madrid punished City in Europe, making relatively light work of matters with a 5-1 win on aggregate in the last 16.

‘Noni Madueke was rapping the whole night’: inside Arsenal’s nightclub title party

Arsenal
‘Noni Madueke was rapping the whole night’: inside Arsenal’s nightclub title party
Ed Aarons
Thu 21 May 2026 21.00 CESTLast modified on Fri 22 May 2026 06.29 CEST
News
https://www.theguardian.com/football/2026/may/21/noni-madueke-was-rapping-the-whole-night-inside-arsenals-nightclub-title-party

Daniel Bull has waited his whole life to see Arsenal win the Premier League and it is fair to say that the 22-year-old from north London will never forget the celebrations on Tuesday night. Having found himself sharing a bottle of champagne with Ian Wright as thousands of supporters gathered outside the Emirates Stadium, the devoted Gunners supporter and two close friends took a gamble as the party was petering out.

“I had just heard a whisper,” Bull says. That whisper was that Arsenal’s players were gathering at the exclusive Tape nightclub in Mayfair after they had watched from the training ground as Bournemouth drew with Manchester City to crown the club champions for the first time since 2004. An Instagram video later posted by Noni Madueke’s mother showed the England forward returning home to much acclaim before immediately announcing, “I’m going out.”

One of Bull’s friends was reluctant to try their luck after the Tape bouncers refused to confirm whether the players were inside, but Bull paid what he describes as “not the cheapest” entry fee. His hunch was proved correct when they immediately bumped into Arsenal’s set-piece coach, Nicolas Jover, the man credited with a pivotal role in the title success.

“I couldn’t believe what was happening,” Bull says. “It’s a very, very exclusive nightclub and we were the only Arsenal fans in there.”

Most of Arsenal’s squad and the manager, Mikel Arteta, were celebrating in a private room, but Bull was able to buy a table nearby that he admits cost him and his friends a small fortune.

“It was only about five steps from the lower part of the club and we could see that Madueke was on the mic for most of the night; he was basically the MC,” Bull says. “He was rapping the whole night.”

A few players also wandered into the main part of the club and Bull remembers speaking to Myles Lewis-Skelly and Ethan Nwaneri, who has just returned from his loan at Marseille. “They were both really friendly,” he says, before revealing that his Scandinavian friend was able to hold a conversation with the Danish midfielder Christian Nørgaard. “Because my mate’s Norwegian he was chatting to Christian Nørgaard, which was quite cool.

“We were in there for about two or three hours, and the next thing you know, we start seeing everyone. So there’s Declan Rice, Mikel Arteta, Viktor Gyökeres, Bukayo Saka, Jurriën Timber and Eberechi Eze. I was with one of my housemates at the pub last night, and he was like: ‘You shook Eze’s hand!’”

A short video of Arteta bellowing “champions of England” on the microphone has gone viral on social media, along with the manager photobombing Rice. The England midfielder was spotted by supporters wandering around the Emirates with Saka, Timber and Eze at 5am because they wanted to soak up the occasion. Rice was “still buzzing” and went off to play nine holes of golf with a friend after a few hours’ sleep.

For Bull, who has been to every Arsenal away game in Europe this season and will be in Budapest for next Saturday’s Champions League final against Paris Saint-Germain, the night started at the Twelve Pins pub in Finsbury Park. He headed down the road as the full-time whistle blew at Bournemouth and couldn’t believe his luck when Wright suddenly appeared alongside him clutching a bottle of champagne, even if the club’s previous record scorer initially struggled to open it.

“It was carnage,” Bull says. “The next thing you know, we start hearing: ‘Ian Wright, Wright, Wright.’ And me and my mate have just somehow ended up next to him. After he had his first sip of champagne, I had the second sip and then my mate has the third sip. The only people who had that champagne bottle were basically my crowd of mates that we go with. And then I’ve now got that bottle at home with me.”

Bull is hoping to get it signed by Wright, part of Arsenal’s title-winning team in 1998, as a memento of an incredible evening that will take some beating.

“It was the definition of a pinch-yourself moment. I was in there thinking: ‘What the hell is going on?’ I think because we just rocked up when we did and we were so chill and happy to pay whatever. It was unbelievable.”

‘My parents didn’t talk about the past’: how director Caroline Huppert recovered her family’s wartime secrets

History books
‘My parents didn’t talk about the past’: how director Caroline Huppert recovered her family’s wartime secrets
Phil Hoad
Fri 22 May 2026 14.00 CEST
News
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2026/may/22/caroline-huppert-une-histoire-cachee-second-world-war-antisemitism-nazi-france

F amilies have a way of appointing their own historians, even if the recruitment process remains obscure. In the late 1990s, Caroline Huppert – the fourth of five siblings, of whom the youngest is actor Isabelle – found herself alone with her father and a tape recorder. Over five days, he opened up about his life before and during the second world war. “I think I had that privileged position with him, because he had a taste for history, too,” she says. “But we didn’t have the same vision. I like the approach of what is called the nouvelle histoire , things like details of daily life in the past. With him, it was more emperors, kings, dates.”

More than 25 years later, their exchanges have led to her memoir, Une Histoire Cachée (A Hidden Story), a work that bundles up quotidian intimacy and big-ticket history in telling the story of how her parents, Raymond and Annick, fell in love. Their relationship so easily might never have happened: he was Jewish, she Catholic, and after they met in 1934 at Paris’s HEC business school, her haute-bourgeois family were opposed to them marrying. A big enough obstacle even before the Nazis invade France , and the young lovers are forced to flee the capital for the Free Zone near Lake Annecy. “I wasn’t aware of any of it in the least,” says the 75-year-old on a phone call from her home in Paris. “My parents weren’t people who talked about the past. They were always absorbed in the present, in action.”

Thanks to her father’s nostalgic volte-face before he died aged 89 in 2003, Huppert began thinking about how to undertake the “archaeology of her family” (her mother died earlier, in 1990). But with a hectic career as director of TV films and screenwriter, she was intimidated by the task – even with her education in history. Then in 2024, another storybook miracle unlocked it for her. While fishing for a pushchair in a storage unit, Huppert’s daughter jostled an old desk her mum had left her; a cache of 150 old letters hidden in a false drawer fell out. “She sent me a photo of them, and I recognised my mother’s writing,” says Huppert. “And this goldmine allowed me to go to the very end of what I wanted to do with the book, because it was a really great source of information about daily life.”

Her book closes with a high-wire climax – which Huppert prefers not to spoil. The courage they inspired in each other came as a surprise, notably “the intrepidness of my mother, who wasn’t afraid of anything and crossed the demarcation line in the boot of a car”. But it’s in the patient logging of banal wartime realities, thanks to Annick’s correspondence, where Une Histoire Cachée also fascinates: the struggles to find food, the freezing conditions in the Savoie house where Raymond ends up fabricating drill bits for a collaborator, how the couple still snatched moments of ephemeral pleasure amid this turmoil.

Such minutiae are especially important as they relate to the Franco-Jewish community during the time, of which there is only “piecemeal” documentation, according to Huppert. Soaking up Raymond and Annick’s routine, you realise how their privations were a direct consequence of pre-war prejudices – when a wary truce had been in place between Jewish and traditional French society since the Dreyfus affair. “I really wanted to describe what antisemitism looked like on a daily basis in French society, even before the Nazis’ racial laws,” says Huppert. “And show the continuity with what the Pétain regime decreed – and to what point it seemed natural to everyone, bit by bit, to put those laws in place.”

Huppert brings a distinctive Jewish slant to a recent mini-boom of Vichy lit and cinema that, like much French output on the occupation, tends to focus rather on questions of collaboration and resistance: the recent films Les Rayons et Les Ombres and Laszlo Nemes’ Moulin , the Cécile Desprairies novel The Propagandist. Daniel Auteuil’s drama La Troisième Nuit, premiering at Cannes, will bolster the Jewish side soon. But whatever the reasons for this surge of interest – whether it’s the looming prospect of a far-right government in France, or newly rising antisemitism – Huppert isn’t tempted to infer any contemporary resonances. “I don’t know anything about that. As an archaeologist, I lean more towards understanding the origins rather than the results. It’s sociologists who look at what is happening now.”

Not only is Huppert categorical about her work in this way, even after exploring her family’s mixed heritage, she seems detached about her Jewish roots. She says she doesn’t feel culturally or religiously more Jewish in the wake of writing – and in any case hates generalising: “It’s annoying to say ‘the Jewish people’. It’s a terrible expression. I don’t see where there’s a Jewish people – there are Jews of all different kinds.”

You wonder if this neutrality isn’t also part of her legacy from her secular father, who refused to convert to Catholicism in support of his kinsfolk – but still raised his family within Catholic norms in the postwar period. There’s something of the same withholding independence in her sister Isabelle’s acting; she has spoken of sharing her father’s tendency towards silence. At any rate, Isabelle is a fan of the book. In a text, she sums up: “A magnificent portrait of a woman, a highly moving homage to our family, and an exciting and superbly researched document of that time.”

If a rapprochement with Jewishness wasn’t Huppert’s principal aim, the notion of lineage does count for her – just as it did for her father a quarter-century ago when he decided to share: “I wanted my children and children’s children, my own posterity, to know this was their history.” But though she’s rescued her parents from the fog of time, she couldn’t do it for everyone. Huppert is still haunted by the story of Françine, a young refugee whom Annick teaches English in the French Basque country, and then crosses paths with a second time in Savoie. The references in her mother’s letters stopped there, and Huppert found no traces online. “I was very touched by the fate of this sensitive young girl whose adolescence was stolen from her. I’ve been worrying about her. I hope she survived.”

Une Histoire Cachée by Caroline Huppert is published by Editions Mercure de France